Two south Naples 34114 communities with very different financial structures. The fees aren’t just different in amount — they’re structured in completely different ways. Here’s the honest comparison, with verified 2026 numbers.
The key insight most buyers miss: Fiddler’s Creek has a two-layer fee structure. Layer one is the mandatory Foundation membership (everyone pays). Layer two is the OPTIONAL Members Club at Marco for golf and beach access — with separate initiation fees of $25,000 or $125,000 plus annual dues. Esplanade by the Islands rolls everything into a single HOA. Apples-to-apples comparison only works once you know that.
Both communities sit in the same zip code (34114) just minutes apart in south Naples, close to Marco Island. Geography is similar. The community design philosophies and how you pay for amenities are very different.
Side-by-side overview
| Esplanade by the Islands | Fiddler’s Creek | |
|---|---|---|
| Developer | Taylor Morrison | Gulf Bay Group of Companies / various builders |
| Location | South Naples · 34114 · near Marco | South Naples · 34114 · near Marco |
| Status | Active new construction (Phase 4) | Established · primarily resale |
| Property types | Single-family, Coach Home, Twin Villa | Single-family, Coach Home, Low-rise condo |
| Membership structure | Single HOA — all amenities bundled | Two-tier: mandatory Foundation + OPTIONAL Members Club at Marco |
| Golf inside the gates? | No | No (golf is via Members Club at Marco at Hammock Bay & The Rookery) |
| Cable TV included in HOA? | No | Yes — bulk Telecommunication Assessment |
| Beach access? | Public beaches at Marco / Tigertail / Naples | Public beaches OR private 10.1-acre Members Cove via Members Club at Marco |
This is the apples-to-apples comparison most useful for buyers. What you have to pay every year, regardless of whether you golf, beach, or just want to live in the community.
Mandatory annual fees, 2026 (verified)
| Component | Esplanade by the Islands (52′ SF) | Fiddler’s Creek |
|---|---|---|
| Operating / Foundation assessment | $3,500.00 | $4,596.00 ($1,149/qtr) |
| Reserve | $250.00 | included above |
| Landscape benefit (by lot) | $1,555.75 | — (varies by neighborhood HOA) |
| Telecommunication / cable TV | not included | $1,250.00 ($312.50/qtr) |
| Food & beverage minimum | $800.00 | none |
| Subtotal annual | $6,105.75 | $5,846.00 + neighborhood HOA |
Source: Esplanade by the Islands Approved 2026 Annual Budget. Fiddler’s Creek Foundation Information Sheet (12.04.25). Coach Home and Low-rise condo owners at Fiddler’s also pay separate neighborhood HOA assessments; verify the specific neighborhood HOA for the home you’re looking at.
This is where Fiddler’s gets meaningfully more expensive at closing for a resale buyer. The Foundation collects a refundable Capital Acquisition Assessment plus a non-refundable Capital Reserve at every conveyance.
One-time fees at closing on a resale
| Closing fee | Esplanade by the Islands | Fiddler’s Creek |
|---|---|---|
| Working Fund / Capital Acquisition | $5,000 (Working Fund) | $30,000 (Capital Acquisition, partially refundable per docs) |
| Capital Reserve | none | $5,000 (Capital Reserve, non-refundable) |
| Total to enter the community | $5,000 | $35,000 |
Fiddler’s Creek closing fees apply to conveyances executed on or after February 1, 2025. Conveyances executed before that date were $18,000 + $2,000. Confirm the current amounts via the Foundation before signing a contract.
Here’s the part that confuses most buyers: golf and beach access at Fiddler’s Creek are not bundled into the mandatory Foundation membership. Those come through a separate private club — The Members Club at Marco — that operates Hammock Bay golf, The Rookery golf, and access to the JW Marriott Marco Island Beach Resort.
You can own a Fiddler’s Creek home without joining The Members Club. Many residents do. But for the buyer who wants the full country-club experience, the Members Club is where the golf course and the private beach come from — and the price is non-trivial.
2026 Members Club at Marco fees
| Membership tier | Initiation | 2026 annual dues |
|---|---|---|
| Full Golf — both courses + JW Marriott + beach | $125,000 ($56,000 refundable on resignation) | $17,172 ($16,200 + 6% tax) |
| Social Beach — JW Marriott + private beach (no golf) | $25,000 (non-refundable) | $6,360 ($6,000 + 6% tax) |
Source: The Members Club at Marco Initiation Fee Structure, effective January 1, 2026. No food & beverage or golf shop minimums; no assessments; 20% F&B / retail discount across all three campuses (Hammock Bay, JW Marriott Marco, The Rookery).
What does it really cost to live at each community? Three scenarios:
Annual carrying cost (mandatory + optional)
| Lifestyle scenario | Esplanade by the Islands (52′ SF) | Fiddler’s Creek |
|---|---|---|
| Resident only — no golf, no private beach | ~$6,106/yr | ~$5,846/yr + neighborhood HOA |
| Social-Beach lifestyle — private beach access | ~$6,106/yr | ~$12,206/yr + $25,000 one-time |
| Full golf lifestyle — golf at both courses + beach | ~$6,106/yr (no on-site golf) | ~$23,018/yr + $125,000 one-time (partly refundable) |
Fiddler’s Creek totals assume Foundation Membership Assessment + Telecommunication Assessment. Add neighborhood HOA for Coach/Condo owners. Esplanade by the Islands totals shown for a 52′ single-family lot — 62′ and 76′ lots are higher.
The takeaway: if you don’t care about golf-inside-a-private-club or the JW Marriott private beach, the two communities cost about the same to live in — just with different things bundled (cable TV is in for Fiddler’s; F&B minimum is in for Esplanade). If you DO want the full country-club lifestyle with private beach and championship golf, Fiddler’s + Members Club at Marco runs roughly 3–4× the annual carrying cost of Esplanade by the Islands.
Vibe: resort-lifestyle community — one-bill simplicity. Strong pickleball culture, active resident clubs.
Vibe: established country-club-style master-planned community with tiered membership. Mature trees, settled feel, broader range of housing types.
12-month single-family median ~$1.0M. Active new construction directly from Taylor Morrison.
Established community. Mostly resale. Multiple sub-neighborhoods, each with its own architecture and neighborhood-specific HOA fee. Current sales data on the SWFL MLS — contact Nick for the current snapshot.
The honest framing: these communities can look similar from the outside — both are gated, resort-style, south Naples, near Marco. The actual financial commitment is meaningfully different once you account for the Members Club layer. If you came to this page trying to pick between them, the right question isn’t “which costs more” — it’s “do you want country-club private beach + golf, or do you want resort-lifestyle simplicity?”
My focus is Esplanade by the Islands — I live the lifestyle, have family in the community, play pickleball at the courts, and have been working in Esplanade since the gates first opened — selling, hosting open houses, and showing every floor plan as it released. I’m also familiar with Fiddler’s Creek and can give you an honest read on the tradeoffs.
If after a real comparison Fiddler’s turns out to be the better fit for your lifestyle, I’m happy to refer you to a colleague who specializes there. Most important thing is that you end up in the right community with eyes wide open about what you’re paying for.
Sources & notes: Esplanade by the Islands figures sourced from the Esplanade by the Islands Community Association Approved 2026 Annual Budget (November 11, 2025). Fiddler’s Creek figures sourced from the Fiddler’s Creek Foundation Information Sheet (December 4, 2025). Members Club at Marco figures sourced from the Members Club at Marco Initiation Fee Structure, effective January 1, 2026. Coach Home and Low-rise condo owners at Fiddler’s Creek also pay separate neighborhood HOA assessments not reflected in the totals above — verify the specific neighborhood’s assessment before relying on the totals shown. Assessment amounts may change; verify current amounts via association documents before relying on these for a transaction. This article is general information, not tax, legal, or financial advice.
Realty ONE Group MVP · The Nicholas Nolan Team
Nicholas Nolan LLC · Florida Real Estate License SL3504588 · 
Living in Naples, listing in Naples, helping people move to Naples. Resident-level local knowledge plus the buyer-side network you need to actually pull off an out-of-state relocation.
Brokerage. Nicholas Nolan (Florida Real Estate License SL3504588) is a licensed real estate sales associate of Realty ONE Group MVP, 1495 Pine Ridge Rd, Naples, FL 34109. The Nicholas Nolan Team is a team operating under the supervision of Realty ONE Group MVP. All real estate services are performed by Realty ONE Group MVP.
Equal Housing Opportunity. We do business in accordance with the Federal Fair Housing Law and equal opportunity housing standards.
Not tax, legal, or insurance advice. Information on this page is for general educational purposes and reflects publicly available sources as of the date noted. Florida tax, residency, homestead, insurance, and Medicare rules change. Consult a licensed Florida CPA, attorney, or insurance professional for advice specific to your situation. We are not a tax, legal, or insurance advisor.
Independent resource. This site is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or operated by Esplanade by the Islands Community Association, Inc., or Taylor Morrison. “Esplanade” and “Esplanade by the Islands” are trademarks of Taylor Morrison; all third-party trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
